Bribery Auckland Council Stock Photo

Bribery and corruption on the Auckland Council

David McNeill

David McNeill

David McNeill

TINZ Director

Reporting from Auckland

Engineering consultancy company director, Stephen Borlase, and Rodney District Council Infrastructure ‘Director’ [Manager] Murray John Noone, have been found guilty of bribery under section 105 of crimes act, and will be sentenced in February.

The case has taken three years to come to court. Noone fought hard for name suppression in 2015, despite being named in prior media coverage.

Borlase’s company Projenz was put into liquidation on Friday 16th December 2016, also affecting directors & shareholders Craig Payne and Scott McIntyre.

Another council officer, Barrie George, earlier pleaded guilty to corruption after receiving $200,000 from prominent roading contractor HiWay Stabilisers. He was sentenced to 9 months’ home detention. Barrie has also been a prosecution witness.

The investigation uncovered evidence of considerable largesse from Projenz to all of Noone’s former roading department, in the form of extravagant lunches & gifts.

Julie Read of the Serious Fraud Office stated: "It appears that within the road maintenance division during this period the acceptance of gratuities was considered the norm. All of us need to recognise that corrupt activity is at risk of gaining momentum if business turns a blind eye."

David Warburton, CEO of Auckland Transport, said the case was not indicative of wider issues in the department.  This appears to be contradicted by the evidence presented in court, and the brash statements of Borlase., This has been a wake-up call to the council to re-evaluate its internal assessments.

As the judge succinctly pointed out, it is an offence to accept gifts connected with official duties.

New Zealand Herald’s Matt Nippert spent considerable time at the 8-week trial. Representative articles include Court hears of council staff's four-figure lunches and Council manager guilty of majority of corruption charges.

TINZ’s role is to promote changes in systems and processes that prevent corruption and strengthen integrity systems, rather than concentrating on individual cases.  TINZ is working with Local Government New Zealand, the Auckland Council and local governments throughout New Zealand to promote transparency, integrity and accountability. We are lucky that behaviour like this is not normal, is unacceptable and clearly illegal in New Zealand. Just the same, that it occurs at all is unacceptable as it is another chink in this country’s reputation for integrity and as such risks harm to everyone.

Actions

Recent Activity

Corruption Perceptions Index 2016 TINZ media release
Transparency International’s 2016 Corruption Perception Index (TI CPI) has found that the New Zealand and Denmark public sectors are the least corrupt in the world. 25 Jan, 2017

TINZ OGP Submission
Transparency International New Zealand (TINZ) submitted recommendations for New Zealand’s second Open Government Partnership (OGP) National Action Plan (NAP). Among the recommendations were a call for more ambition in creating NAPs and developing channels of communication for improving engagement with citizens. 19 Aug, 2016

Safeguarding the public interest in research
1 Aug, 2016

EU and New Zealand tax transparency
1 Aug, 2016

London Summit 2016 NZ Statement Commitments Progress
31 Jul, 2016

New Zealand Country Statement Anti Corruption Summit London 2016
29 May, 2016

Shewan Inquiry Submission Media Release
TINZ has provided its submission to the Shewan Inquiry calling on the government to widen the terms of reference to protect New Zealand's reputation and future proof our laws following the release of the "Panama papers". 21 May, 2016

CPI 2015 TINZ Media Release
Corruption Free? NZ drops again. New Zealand has fallen to fourth place in the Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI). 26 Jan, 2016